I came across this questions on one of the online Java Tests. The options were 4,5,8 and any number of times.
I have only used one inner class, but have never tried multiple ones. I was wondering if anyone knows the answer.
I came across this questions on one of the online Java Tests. The options were 4,5,8 and any number of times.
I have only used one inner class, but have never tried multiple ones. I was wondering if anyone knows the answer.
I tried on my own: The answer is any number of times. The following is my test class, I had no compilation errors.
public class Test { public Test () { } public static void main (String args[]) { new Test (); } class Test2 { class Test3 { class Test4 { class Test5{ class Test6{ class Test7{ class Test8{ class Test9 { } } } } } } } } }
It s a completely irrelevant question and I hope they weren t using the results for anything important. I guess the answer they were looking for was any number of times but in practice there will be a limit in any given implementation of Java. If it s not defined directly it will be determined by something like the maximum file size, or some other (possibly undocumented) internal limit. The best way to find out is to try it.
Update: 30 works, but 300 gives this error:
A.java:3: error while writing B0.B1.B2.B3.B4.B5.B6.B7.B8.B9.B10.B11.B12.B13.B14.
B15.B16.B17.B18.B19.B20.B21.B22.B23.B24.B25.B26.B27.B28.B29.B30.B31.B32.B33.B34.
B35.B36.B37.B38.B39.B40.B41.B42.B43.B44.B45.B46.B47.B48.B49.B50.B51.B52.B53.B54.
B55.B56.B57.B58.B59.B60.B61.B62.B63.B64.B65.B66.B67.B68.B69.B70.B71.B72.B73.B74.
B75.B76.B77.B78.B79.B80.B81.B82.B83.B84.B85.B86.B87.B88.B89.B90.B91.B92.B93.B94.
B95.B96.B97.B98.B99.B100.B101.B102.B103.B104.B105.B106.B107.B108.B109.B110.B111.
B112.B113.B114.B115.B116.B117.B118.B119.B120.B121.B122.B123.B124.B125.B126.B127.
B128.B129.B130.B131.B132.B133.B134.B135.B136.B137.B138.B139.B140.B141.B142.B143.
B144.B145.B146.B147.B148.B149.B150.B151.B152.B153.B154.B155.B156.B157.B158.B159.
B160.B161.B162.B163.B164.B165.B166.B167.B168.B169.B170.B171.B172.B173.B174.B175.
B176.B177.B178.B179.B180.B181.B182.B183.B184.B185.B186.B187.B188.B189.B190.B191.
B192.B193.B194.B195.B196.B197.B198.B199.B200.B201.B202.B203.B204.B205.B206.B207.
B208.B209.B210.B211.B212.B213.B214.B215.B216.B217.B218.B219.B220.B221.B222.B223.
B224.B225.B226.B227.B228.B229.B230.B231.B232.B233.B234.B235.B236.B237.B238.B239.
B240.B241.B242.B243.B244.B245.B246.B247.B248.B249.B250.B251.B252.B253.B254.B255.
B256.B257.B258.B259.B260.B261.B262.B263.B264.B265.B266.B267.B268.B269.B270.B271.
B272.B273.B274.B275.B276.B277.B278.B279.B280.B281.B282.B283.B284.B285.B286.B287.
B288.B289.B290.B291.B292.B293.B294.B295.B296.B297.B298.B299: B0$B1$B2$B3$B4$B5$B
6$B7$B8$B9$B10$B11$B12$B13$B14$B15$B16$B17$B18$B19$B20$B21$B22$B23$B24$B25$B26$B
27$B28$B29$B30$B31$B32$B33$B34$B35$B36$B37$B38$B39$B40$B41$B42$B43$B44$B45$B46$B
47$B48$B49$B50$B51$B52$B53$B54$B55$B56$B57$B58$B59$B60$B61$B62$B63$B64$B65$B66$B
67$B68$B69$B70$B71$B72$B73$B74$B75$B76$B77$B78$B79$B80$B81$B82$B83$B84$B85$B86$B
87$B88$B89$B90$B91$B92$B93$B94$B95$B96$B97$B98$B99$B100$B101$B102$B103$B104$B105
$B106$B107$B108$B109$B110$B111$B112$B113$B114$B115$B116$B117$B118$B119$B120$B121
$B122$B123$B124$B125$B126$B127$B128$B129$B130$B131$B132$B133$B134$B135$B136$B137
$B138$B139$B140$B141$B142$B143$B144$B145$B146$B147$B148$B149$B150$B151$B152$B153
$B154$B155$B156$B157$B158$B159$B160$B161$B162$B163$B164$B165$B166$B167$B168$B169
$B170$B171$B172$B173$B174$B175$B176$B177$B178$B179$B180$B181$B182$B183$B184$B185
$B186$B187$B188$B189$B190$B191$B192$B193$B194$B195$B196$B197$B198$B199$B200$B201
$B202$B203$B204$B205$B206$B207$B208$B209$B210$B211$B212$B213$B214$B215$B216$B217
$B218$B219$B220$B221$B222$B223$B224$B225$B226$B227$B228$B229$B230$B231$B232$B233
$B234$B235$B236$B237$B238$B239$B240$B241$B242$B243$B244$B245$B246$B247$B248$B249
$B250$B251$B252$B253$B254$B255$B256$B257$B258$B259$B260$B261$B262$B263$B264$B265
$B266$B267$B268$B269$B270$B271$B272$B273$B274$B275$B276$B277$B278$B279$B280$B281
$B282$B283$B284$B285$B286$B287$B288$B289$B290$B291$B292$B293$B294$B295$B296$B297
$B298$B299.class (The filename, directory name, or volume label syntax is incorr
ect)
Code used to generate source (written in Python):
n = input()
print "class A{public static void main(String[] a){}}
"
print .join("class B%d{" % x for x in range(n)) + } * n
Disappointing. I was actually hoping it would be a lot more. I wonder if it could get much further on another system which allows longer filenames.
Hmmm. I know that the online Java test you refer to is a lousy one. Does that count?
(This is the kind of limit that is irrelevant in practical experience. A similarly ridiculously question would be, "What is the maximum length of a function in bytes?")
The true answer is none of the above. Javac will of course allow arbitrary nesting, but the underlying file system and/or OS have restrictions. We found recently that during startup the JVM running a Glassfish Java EE application server instance will hold open files to each .class during loading/JIT compilation. If you re running CentOS Linux say, the default limit on open files/process is 1024, so if you have a lot of classes being loaded at once and don t set the ulimit -n
to a higher value, the JVM will hit "too many open files". And @Mark Byers example shows that the .class file names get very long and can hit the file system name length limit, if there is one.
As a follow-up to Mark s trial on windows - a bit silly but fun nonetheless - I did a trial on AIX 5.3.
91 subclasses deep is ok, number 92 results in the following error:
-rw-r--r-- 1 root system 12813 Nov 24 15:15 A.class
Main class=class A
count=90 class=A$B$C$D$E$F$G$H$I$J$K$L$M$N$O$P$Q$R$S$T$U$V$W$X$Y$Z$AA$AB$AC$AD$AE$AF$AG$AH$AI$AJ$AK$AL$AM$AN$AO$AP$AQ$AR$AS$AT$AU$AV$AW$AX$AY$AZ$BA$BB$BC$BD$BE$BF$BG$BH$BI$BJ$BK$BL$BM$BN$BO$BP$BQ$BR$BS$BT$BU$BV$BW$BX$BY$BZ$CA$CB$CC$CD$CE$CF$CG$CH$CI$CJ$CK$CL$CM
-rw-r--r-- 1 root system 13081 Nov 24 15:16 A.class
Main class=class A
count=91 class=A$B$C$D$E$F$G$H$I$J$K$L$M$N$O$P$Q$R$S$T$U$V$W$X$Y$Z$AA$AB$AC$AD$AE$AF$AG$AH$AI$AJ$AK$AL$AM$AN$AO$AP$AQ$AR$AS$AT$AU$AV$AW$AX$AY$AZ$BA$BB$BC$BD$BE$BF$BG$BH$BI$BJ$BK$BL$BM$BN$BO$BP$BQ$BR$BS$BT$BU$BV$BW$BX$BY$BZ$CA$CB$CC$CD$CE$CF$CG$CH$CI$CJ$CK$CL$CM$CN
A.java:93: error while writing A.B.C.D.E.F.G.H.I.J.K.L.M.N.O.P.Q.R.S.T.U.V.W.X.Y.Z.AA.AB.AC.AD.AE.AF.AG.AH.AI.AJ.AK.AL.AM.AN.AO.AP.AQ.AR.AS.AT.AU.AV.AW.AX.AY.AZ.BA.BB.BC.BD.BE.BF.BG.BH.BI.BJ.BK.BL.BM.BN.BO.BP.BQ.BR.BS.BT.BU.BV.BW.BX.BY.BZ.CA.CB.CC.CD.CE.CF.CG.CH.CI.CJ.CK.CL.CM.CN.CO: A$B$C$D$E$F$G$H$I$J$K$L$M$N$O$P$Q$R$S$T$U$V$W$X$Y$Z$AA$AB$AC$AD$AE$AF$AG$AH$AI$AJ$AK$AL$AM$AN$AO$AP$AQ$AR$AS$AT$AU$AV$AW$AX$AY$AZ$BA$BB$BC$BD$BE$BF$BG$BH$BI$BJ$BK$BL$BM$BN$BO$BP$BQ$BR$BS$BT$BU$BV$BW$BX$BY$BZ$CA$CB$CC$CD$CE$CF$CG$CH$CI$CJ$CK$CL$CM$CN$CO.class (A file or path name is too long.)
static class CO {
^
1 error
The generated Java source looks like:
class A {
static class B {
void run() {
System.out.println("count=" + 2 + " class=" + B.class.getName() + "
");
}
}
public static void main(String[] a){
System.out.println("Main class=" + A.class + "
");
(new A.B()).run();
}
}
Yes you can nest a class infinitely in Java.
Hi have this j2ee web application developed using spring framework. I have a problem with rendering mnessages in nihongo characters from the properties file. I tried converting the file to ascii using ...
Check this, List<String> list = new ArrayList<String>(); for (int i = 0; i < 10000; i++) { String value = (""+UUID.randomUUID().getLeastSignificantBits()).substring(3, ...
I am in the middle of solving a problem where I think it s best suited for a decorator and a state pattern. The high level setting is something like a sandwich maker and dispenser, where I have a set ...
I have been trying to execute a MS SQL Server stored procedure via JDBC today and have been unsuccessful thus far. The stored procedure has 1 input and 1 output parameter. With every combination I ...
I have a system which contains multiple applications connected together using JMS and Spring Integration. Messages get sent along a chain of applications. [App A] -> [App B] -> [App C] We set a ...
If I m given two Java Libraries in Jar format, 1 having no bells and whistles, and the other having lots of them that will mostly go unused.... my question is: How will the larger, mostly unused ...
I have a Class variable that holds a certain type and I need to get a variable that holds the corresponding array class. The best I could come up with is this: Class arrayOfFooClass = java.lang....
I m working on a Java desktop application that reads and writes from/to different files. I think a better solution would be to replace the file system by a SQLite database. How hard is it to migrate ...