English 中文(简体)
SimpleDB vs Tokyo Cabinet
原标题:

Has anybody compared SimpleDB and Tokyo Cabinet for performance and scalability? I m coding my project against SimpleDB at the moment and considering benchmarking TC, be nice if somebody had already done it and could tell me whether it s worth testing my specific storage and searching operations. If not I ll run some direct comparisons and blog the results.

Project is using Ubuntu 9.1 & Ruby 1.8.7 on an Amazon EC2 small instance (for now).

最佳回答

I have done a project in TokyoCabinet, though several months ago, so the landscape may have changed since then.

I initially looked at SimpleDB because I was certain I was going to want to run everything on Amazon s EC2, but after actually looking at how much that would cost, it seemed pretty ridiculous, heh.

Also, the lag between my server and SimpleDB was unbearable. So on that note alone, I trashed the SimpleDB option and went with TC.

In actuality, I went with Tokyo Tyrant, and built a stupidly simple ORM on top of it that allowed me to read from the local TT instance and write to the "home" server, which then replicated out to all the remote servers (which ran in the cloud on demand).

That operation (writing "home" and replicating out) took extremely little time compared to SimpleDB. I have no idea why it was so slow for my server.

So in short, I went with neither, haha, but did stick to the Tokyo* line of software.

问题回答

暂无回答




相关问题
Ruby parser in Java

The project I m doing is written in Java and parsers source code files. (Java src up to now). Now I d like to enable parsing Ruby code as well. Therefore I am looking for a parser in Java that parses ...

rails collection_select vs. select

collection_select and select Rails helpers: Which one should I use? I can t see a difference in both ways. Both helpers take a collection and generates options tags inside a select tag. Is there a ...

RubyCAS-Client question: Rails

I ve installed RubyCAS-Client version 2.1.0 as a plugin within a rails app. It s working, but I d like to remove the ?ticket= in the url. Is this possible?

Ordering a hash to xml: Rails

I m building an xml document from a hash. The xml attributes need to be in order. How can this be accomplished? hash.to_xml

multiple ruby extension modules under one directory

Can sources for discrete ruby extension modules live in the same directory, controlled by the same extconf.rb script? Background: I ve a project with two extension modules, foo.so and bar.so which ...

Text Editor for Ruby-on-Rails

guys which text editor is good for Rubyonrails? i m using Windows and i was using E-Texteditor but its not free n its expired now can anyone plese tell me any free texteditor? n which one is best an ...

热门标签