It does not make sense to cast ComponentClass(Components[i]).Visible, because .Visible needs to be of a specific class, in order to be compiled properly. Therefore, you need to specify the exact class that should be cast to. For instance, if TControl has a .Visible property, but a derived class creates a new kind of .Visible property, the compiler would not know, which of these two properties it should compile for.
So the question is, do you want to invert the TControl.Visible, then you should write (Components[i] as TControl).Visible. I guess that s what you want.
If you want to invert the .Visible of any TControl descendent, no matter if it relates to the control being Visible or not, and no matter if it is related to TControl.Visible or not, then you should go for the RTTI solution described elsewhere.