English 中文(简体)
How does Voldemort compare to Cassandra?
原标题:

How does Voldemort compare to Cassandra?

I m not talking about size of community and only want to hear from people who have actually used both.

Especially I m interested in:

  • How they dynamically scale when adding and removing nodes
  • Query performance
  • How they scale when adding nodes (linear)?
  • Write speed
最佳回答

Voldemort s support for adding nodes was just added recently (this month). So I would expect Cassandra s to be more robust given the longer time to cook and a larger community testing.

Both are fast (> 10k ops/s per machine). Because of their storage designs, I would expect Cassandra to be faster at writes, and Voldemort to be faster at reads. I would also expect Cassandra s performance to degrade less as the amount of data per node increases. And of course if you need more than just a key/value data model Cassandra s ColumnFamily model wins.

I don t know of any head-to-head benchmarks since the one done for NoSQL SF last June, which found Cassandra to be somewhat faster at whatever workload mix he was using. (The "vpork" talk from http://blog.oskarsson.nu/2009/06/nosql-debrief.html) 8 months is an eternity with projects under this much development, though.

问题回答

Some additional comments:

  • Regarding write speed, Cassandra should be faster -- it is designed to be faster to write than read (you can avoid immediate disk hit for writes due to specialized way storage is done)

But main difference I think is actually not performance but feature set: Voldemort is strictly a key/value store (currently anyway), whereas Cassandra can offer range queries (with order-preserving partitioner), and bit more structure around data (column families etc). Former is an important consideration for design; latter IMO less so, you can always structure BLOB data on client side.





相关问题
what is wrong with this mysql code

$db_user="root"; $db_host="localhost"; $db_password="root"; $db_name = "fayer"; $conn = mysqli_connect($db_host,$db_user,$db_password,$db_name) or die ("couldn t connect to server"); // perform query ...

Users asking for denormalized database

I am in the early stages of developing a database-driven system and the largest part of the system revolves around an inheritance type of relationship. There is a parent entity with about 10 columns ...

Easiest way to deal with sample data in Java web apps?

I m writing a Java web app in my free time to learn more about development. I m using the Stripes framework and eventually intend to use hibernate and MySQL For the moment, whilst creating the pages ...

join across databases with nhibernate

I am trying to join two tables that reside in two different databases. Every time, I try to join I get the following error: An association from the table xxx refers to an unmapped class. If the ...

How can I know if such value exists in database? (ADO.NET)

For example, I have a table, and there is a column named Tags . I want to know if value programming exists in this column. How can I do this in ADO.NET? I did this: OleDbCommand cmd = new ...

Convert date to string upon saving a doctrine record

I m trying to migrate one of my PHP projects to Doctrine. I ve never used it before so there are a few things I don t understand. In my current code, I have a class similar to this: class ...

热门标签