Question

I m trying to do something that is conceptually similar to this, but can t seem to get it to work (error shown at end) any ideas?

#include <stdio.h>

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR(prefix) prefix##_def_##SUFFIX
  printf( "%d
" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

// untitled:8: error: ‘abc_def_SUFFIX’ undeclared (first use in this function)

Answer 1

You just need additional indirection:

#include <stdio.h>

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR3(prefix, suffix) prefix##_def_##suffix
  #define VAR2(prefix, suffix) VAR3(prefix, suffix)
  #define VAR(prefix) VAR2(prefix, SUFFIX)
  printf( "%d
" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

Even though it looks redundant, it s not.

Answer 2

The usual idiom for correctly using the stringizing (#) or token pasting (##) pre-processing operators is to use a 2nd level of indirection. (What are the applications of the ## preprocessor operator and gotchas to consider?).

#define STRINGIFY2( x) #x
#define STRINGIFY(x) STRINGIFY2(x)

#define PASTE2( a, b) a##b
#define PASTE( a, b) PASTE2( a, b)

Then:

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR(prefix) PASTE( prefix, PASTE( _def_, SUFFIX))
  printf( "%d
" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

Should give you the results you re looking for.

Basically, what happens is that processing of the # and ## operators takes place before macro replacement. Then another round of macro replacement occurs. So if you want macros to be used along with those operations you have to use a 1st level that simply does the replacement - otherwise the stringizing or pasting happens first, and the macros aren t macros anymore- they re whatever the 1st round of stringizing/pasting produces.

To put it more directly - the first level of macro allows the macro parameters to be replaced, then the 2nd level of macro replacement does the stringify/token-pasting operation.

Answer 3

This works with sufficient levels of indirection. While another answer is plenty adequate, I want offer this chunk of code as a demo:

#define SUFFIX ghi

#define VAR1(prefix) prefix##_def_##SUFFIX
VAR1(abc)

#define VAR2_(prefix, sfx) prefix##_def_##sfx
#define VAR2(prefix) VAR2_(prefix,SUFFIX)
VAR2(abc)

#define VAR3_(prefix, sfx) prefix##_def_##sfx
#define VAR3x(prefix,sfx) VAR3_(prefix,sfx)
#define VAR3(prefix) VAR3x(prefix,SUFFIX)
VAR3(abc)

Save this is a text file, x.c, and only preprocess it.

gcc -E x.c

Observe and ponder. I don t quite understand it entirely myself. Just spend two hours trying to get a macro using stringify to work. It is interesting to see that double indirection is sometimes needed.

友情链接